Understanding Shame & Guilt
What They Are, How to Tell the Difference, and Why It Matters
Emotions like shame and guilt can feel overwhelming, confusing, and even paralyzing—but understanding their differences and how they operate is a crucial step toward emotional growth and stronger relationships. Drawing on the research of Brené Brown, a pioneering shame researcher, this blog explores what shame and guilt are, how they impact individuals and couples, and practical strategies for building shame resilience.
Shame vs. Guilt: What’s the Difference?
At first glance, shame and guilt might feel similar – they both stir discomfort, self-reflection, and a desire to change – but they are fundamentally different in focus:
● Guilt is about behavior: “I did something wrong.”
● Shame is about self: “I am wrong.”
Brené Brown emphasizes that guilt can be productive – it signals that our actions have caused harm and motivates us to repair relationships or make better choices. Shame, on the other hand, is corrosive. It tells us that our very essence is flawed and unworthy of connection. While guilt invites reflection, shame fosters isolation, self-criticism, and secrecy.
Why Shame Matters in Relationships
Shame is not just an individual experience – it lives in the context of relationships. In couples, shame can show up as:
● Emotional withdrawal or shutting down
● Over-defensiveness or perfectionism
● Avoidance of vulnerability
● Difficulty expressing needs or admitting mistakes
Attachment theory helps explain why. Shame often gets in the way of secure bonds by making partners fearful of rejection or judgment. In attachment-based couples therapy, an emotionally focused therapist helps couples recognize these shame-driven cycles, unpack their root causes, and rebuild trust through compassion and vulnerability.
The Role of Guilt in Healthy Emotional Awareness
Unlike shame, guilt can be an emotional guide. It alerts us when our actions have harmed someone or violated our personal values. Feeling guilt can:
● Prompt apologies or reparative actions
● Strengthen empathy and understanding in relationships
● Support ethical and moral growth
Importantly, guilt does not attack identity – it targets behavior, making it a manageable, actionable emotion. In this way, guilt supports both therapy and marriage counseling by helping partners notice patterns and make constructive changes.
Shame Resilience: Lessons from Brené Brown, PhD
Brené Brown’s work on shame provides a roadmap for building shame resilience, which is the ability to recognize shame, move through it, and maintain connection rather than retreating into secrecy. Her research highlights several
key strategies:
1. Recognize Shame Triggers
Identify situations, thoughts, or feedback that provoke feelings of inadequacy. Awareness is the first step to breaking shame’s grip.
2. Talk About It
Brown emphasizes that shame thrives in secrecy. Sharing feelings with trusted individuals – friends, therapists, or partners – reduces shame’s intensity.
3. Practice Empathy
Respond to yourself and others with empathy rather than judgment. Empathy interrupts shame cycles and fosters relational safety.
4. Own Your Story
Accept your imperfections without letting them define your worth. Shame resilience involves understanding that everyone has struggles and shortcomings.
5. Cultivate Connection
The antidote to shame is connection. Feeling safe, seen, and valued in relationships creates a buffer against shame’s isolating effects.
In couples counseling at Restored Counseling & Wellness Center, these principles are applied to create emotionally safe spaces where partners can express vulnerability without fear of judgment. Practicing shame resilience together strengthens trust and intimacy.
How Shame and Guilt Interact
It’s common to experience shame and guilt simultaneously. For example, someone might feel guilt for snapping at a partner and shame for thinking, “I’m a bad partner.” Understanding which emotion is primary is critical for emotional growth:
● Primary guilt: Motivates repair and learning
● Primary shame: Triggers withdrawal, self-criticism, and relational tension
In therapy, individuals learn to distinguish between guilt and shame, process each emotion appropriately, and cultivate self-compassion. An attachment focused and emotionally focused therapist can help couples break the cycle of shame-driven disconnection.
Practical Strategies for Managing Shame and Guilt
Here are some strategies grounded in both research and clinical practice:
1. Name the Emotion
Labeling feelings as shame or guilt can reduce intensity and clarify your response.
2. Use Self-Compassion
Treat yourself as you would a loved one – kindly, nonjudgmentally, and patiently.
3. Journal Reflectively
Explore triggers, thoughts, and behaviors linked to shame and guilt. Journaling helps process emotion and identify patterns or “parts” of self that might feel shameful or have likely felt shameful before and are simply remembering.
4. Communicate Vulnerably in Relationships
In attachment-based couples therapy or personal reflection, openly express feelings without expecting perfection – vulnerability builds trust and connection.
5. Engage in Values-Based Action
When guilt arises, focus on actionable steps aligned with your values. This transforms guilt from a painful emotion into productive growth.
Why Understanding Shame and Guilt Matters
Mastering the differences between shame and guilt is more than an academic exercise – it’s a tool for emotional literacy, self-compassion, and stronger relationships. By learning to identify these emotions, communicate about them effectively, and cultivate shame resilience, individuals and couples can break destructive cycles, repair relational wounds, and create more authentic, fulfilling connections.
Brené Brown reminds us: “Shame cannot survive empathy.” Understanding shame and guilt, and responding with empathy and curiosity rather than judgment, is a transformative step in emotional growth.
If shame or guilt have been quietly shaping your relationship, therapy can help. Book a session today for individual therapy, couples therapy, or marriage counseling at Restored Counseling & Wellness Center – and learn how to turn these emotions into opportunities for resilience, compassion, and deeper connection.
Schedule a session today →
________________________________________
Up next: Decoding Pain-Based Emotions
About This Blog Series
This post is part of our Gift of Emotions blog series at Restored Counseling & Wellness Center in Gilbert, AZ. In this 12-part series, we explore how emotions shape our lives and relationships, from understanding their biological and energetic roots to learning practical tools for naming, processing, and expressing them. Each article is designed to help individuals and couples strengthen emotional literacy, deepen connection, and support personal well-being.
Explore the full series:
Blog 1: What Are Emotions, Really? – Understanding Sensation, Biochemistry & Energy in Motion
Blog 2: How Emotions Are Stored or Released in the Body – The Science of Emotional Processing
Blog 3: What Is Alexithymia (and Why Is It So Common?) – Understanding Emotional Blindness in Relationships
Blog 4: Why You Can’t Skip Feeling Your Feelings – The Cost of Emotional Avoidance for You and Your Relationship
Blog 5: How to Name It to Tame It – The Neuroscience of Labeling Emotions
Blog 6: The Utility of Anger & Passion – Anger Isn’t the Enemy— – t’s Information
Blog 7: The Hidden Wisdom of Fear – Fear as Risk Assessment, Not Weakness
Blog 8: Understanding Shame & Guilt – What They Are, How to Tell the Difference, and Why It Matters
Blog 9: Decoding Pain-Based Emotions – Why Grief, Loneliness, and Despair Deserve Our Attention
Blog 10: Cultivating Joy & Love in Relationships – Celebration and Connection as Emotional Anchors
Blog 11: Mapping the Emotional Spectrum – Understanding Primary, Secondary, and Blended Emotions
Blog 12: Emotional Integration Through Parts Work and EFT – How IFS and EFT Help Us Heal and Connect
Restored Counseling & Wellness Center
633 E. Ray Rd. Ste 131
Gilbert, AZ 85296
Phone: 480-256-2999
Text: 480-256-2829